Question by alex: Can you find a skeptical article on Roth IRA vs Traditional IRA?
Most published articles paint a very favorable picture of Roth IRA versus the Traditional IRA (and other IRA-like plans). I have done my own analysis and I honestly think the Roth is a clever government scheme to collect more taxes, and under no circumstances have I been able to think up a scenario where the individual taxpayer/investor comes out ahead with a Roth. Can you point out any well-written article that supports my opinion?
Thanks
I am not looking to debate my findings. I just want to find people who agree.
Best answer:
Answer by Tony
It might help if you post the analysis you did proving your theory.
Add your own answer in the comments!
Question by clash_of_civilizations: How do I calculate taxes when converting a Traditional IRA with TIPS to a Roth IRA?
I have a traditional IRA which contains TIPS (treasury inflated protected securities). How do I calculate taxes when converting the IRA to a Roth IRA?
Best answer:
Answer by Robert B
TIPS has nothing to do with it. You are converting dollars put away before paying taxes to dollars put away after you pay taxes. Figure out your tax rate and multiply by the amount in the IRA. Can get gruesome. Why convert??? Your tax impact should be less when you retire and you withdraw your money at 70 and 1/2.
Add your own answer in the comments!
Question by Brian T: Is it possible to change a Roth IRA to a traditional IRA?
I am young, and I know most financial advisors/calculators out there tell you I would stand to benefit from being in a ROTH IRA. However, after researching this, I know longer believe there’s any guarantee the gov’t will keep the policy of not taxing my returns when I retire 30 years from now. I’d rather take the tax benefit now. Your thoughts?
Best answer:
Answer by dan
If you contributed the money into the Roth this year (2007) you can do what is called a “recharacterization.” The company you invest with will have a form to fill out. The only thing is, you can recharacterize THIS year’s contribution back to the traditional IRA, but any contributions you made to a Roth in prior years cannot be recharacterized.
What do you think? Answer below!
Question by ferggkeane: I want to rollover my traditional ira to a Roth ira verses?
I only have $ 5000 in traditional, and want to roll it over now because i’m taxed in the 15% tax range. And when i but it in a roth ira, it’ll be tax free when i take it out when i retire. Verses the traditional ira, which would be taxed at a higher rate when i retire in 20 years, ( that is if i’m in a higher tax braket). Does this sound like a smart thing to do?
Best answer:
Answer by badgerboise
Rolling it over to a Roth IRA is a fine idea to prevent being taxed on future earnings. However, bear in mind that if the $ 5000 you presently have in the traditional IRA was deposited as a tax exempt, you will be required to pay the tax on that amount in the year you roll it over. If you do a rollover, it is easier if you do not let the money pass through your hands in making the transfer. That way if a snag occurs, you are not responsible for any penalties or taxes.
Give your answer to this question below!
I would like to roll-over Traditional IRA to Roth IRA in March 2011 . I’m 50, early retiree and physically outside the US; my unearned income from(dividend,investment and interest)and no other earned income.
What are the tax consequences? Or Should I roll-over part of my Traditional IRA into Roth IRA. I’m really concern about the tax any potential tax ramification of such move. Please advise. Thank you.
Question by jekelnHide: Foreign earned income exclusion and Traditional IRA to Roth IRA conversion taxes/ capital gains?
I qualify for foreign earned income exclusion. This shows as a negative on income on the tax form. If I convert a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA, the IRS will withhold some taxes. Since my income is negative, can I get these taxes back at the end of the year? Alternatively, can my negative income offset capital gain taxes?
Using the Turbotax program, it takes the value from form 2555, and places it as a negative number in form 1040. Reading the instructions from form 2555, it says to place the value in parenthesis which indicates a negative, correct?
Best answer:
Answer by Jss
How can you have negative income unless you have loss from business or capital loss?
Just making sure that you are doing Form 2555 correctly.
Yes, it is always better to withdraw from IRA only when you have minimum income
For articles on your U.S. tax return, http://taxipay.blogspot.com/2008/04/list-of-articles.html
Know better? Leave your own answer in the comments!
I qualify for foreign earned income exclusion. This shows as a negative on income on the tax form. If I convert a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA, the IRS will withhold some taxes. Since my income is negative, can I get these taxes back at the end of the year? Alternatively, can my negative income offset capital gain taxes?
Using the Turbotax program, it takes the value from form 2555, and places it as a negative number in form 1040. Reading the instructions from form 2555, it says to place the value in parenthesis which indicates a negative, correct?
So, i heard there are technically 2 types of traditional iras. The tax deductible/tax-deffered, or non tax deductible.
If someone is not eligible for tax deductible, why would someone want a non-tax deductible traditional ira. especially if the have to pay taxes twice. once when they go in, and once when they go out.
it just doesnt make sense why they would even offer it as a choice, what am i missing?
CCH released the amounts on 9/29/09 to subscribers of their service.
if someone under age 59 1/2 wants to take money out of a Traditional IRA, they would have to pay a 10 % penalty and taxes. But what if they converted the Traditional IRA to a Roth IRA first? (and they can maybe convert only the amount they need). Then – as I understand Roth IRAs – there is no 10% penalty to withdraw from a Roth. Is this true?
Also, Can you w/d from a Roth anytime without incurring or do you have to wait 5 years after conversion?
Roth ira, roth ira rules,what is roth,retirement plan roth ira 2010,roth ira qualification,what does a roth ira do,ira for minors,simple roth ira calculator